There is some complaint that the resource management/attrition aspects of Old School games leads some dungeoneers to game the system by adopting the 'five minute workday'. Basically, once HP are low, magical resources and special abilities have been depleted, and the dangers of the unknown loom ever larger, the adventuring party retreats to a defensible room, barricades themselves inside, and heals, rests, and recuperates. This is the way you would play a C'RPG', so why not an RPG?
Well, there's nothing wrong with that as a tactic. But an RPG is judged/refereed/games mastered by a living, imaginative person, not dead lines of script. And that person is responsible for the behaviour of the rest of the world, including (but not limited to) the monsters of the underworld. There has been endless discussion of the way that intelligent, social monsters can disrupt these kinds of PC tactics. But even the most mindless of monsters can threaten a five minute workday routine; one word, ROMERO!
Since Night of the Living Dead re-animated the zombie as a horror staple, the standard scenario has seen surviving humans adopting the tactics of the 'five minute workday' and coming unstuck. Resources continue to dwindle. The sheer weight of of the undead on the barricades renders the defensible position a deathtrap. The horror, the horror, sends N/PCs insane (even if you don't have a sanity mechanic for PCs, they've brought henchmen and hirelings, no?).
And even when the five minute workday is so well organised that it prodiuces something akin to the moment of post-apocalyptic, post-scarcity utopia in Dawn of the Dead, there are always NPC parties interested in the same treasures. Some of those treasures are already in the PCs' possession...
Sleep well in the dungeon.
Well, I hate to show up here and bash D&D, but I will anyway. The game is rigged for boredom. Obviously, nothing interesting gets done on these inevitable 5 minute work days. Another example is material components for spells which makes players run around shopping instead of adventuring. My friends would handle this by using magic points instead of memorizing spells and ignoring material components.ReplyDelete
Ah, well, despite a fondess for the 'flavour' of material components, in play I've always handled the majority of them as assumed (of course robbery or other disasters could challenge this assumption). A few rare exceptions would be items to be gained by adventure, and therefore (hopefully) not boring.Delete
However, if D&D is 'rigged for boredom', which 'dungeoneering' systems are not. I'm genuinely asking for recommendations. I'm itching to run Advanced Fighting Fantasy 2e, Dragon Warriors, and Dungeon Crawl Classics (D&Dish, but quite different in tone). And WFRP calls to be, like a siren...
A good point, well stated!ReplyDelete
And roleplaying does need more Murder Hobos...
I would like to say that the 'five minute work day' has never been a problem in games that I have GMd. Maybe that is because none of my players have much experience playing CRPGs where the 'fight, rest, fight' routine is the optimum tactic. Maybe it is because I don't create scenarios where that is the optimum tactic (in Matt Finch's Old School Primer there is some advice on avoiding these kinds of problems by making 'time' another resource for the players to manage). Maybe it is because the players themselves don't want the game to be boring, and are playing accordingly.Delete